The Difference Between a Smoke Detector & a Heat Detector

Smoke Detector

Smoke detector senses smoke in the air and sets off an alarm to warn people of a possible fire. There are two main types: ionization smoke detectors, which react quickly to fast-burning fires, and photoelectric smoke detectors, which are better at detecting slow, smoldering fires. Many modern smoke detectors use both technologies for better protection.

Heat Detector

Heat detectors detect fires by sensing the increase in temperature. Heat detectors monitor the temperature of a room or area, identifying rising heat levels to detect potential fires. Unlike smoke detectors that sense smoke, heat detectors respond to high temperatures or sudden heat increases to detect fires.

By now, you've probably heard about smoke detectors and heat detectors. But have you ever thought about the crucial role they play in protecting lives? These devices stand as silent guardians, always on high alert, ready to warn occupants at the first sign of danger relating to fire. Whether it's the rapid spread of flames or the creeping threat of smoldering smoke, heat and smoke detectors provide the crucial seconds needed to evacuate safely or extinguish a fire before it turns catastrophic.Think of them as your personal fire-watchers, tirelessly monitoring the environment, ensuring that you're alerted when there is a fire.

ItemsSmoke DetectorHeat Detector
FunctionalityDetects the presence of smokeDetects increase in temperature in an area
TypesIonization and photoelectricFixed temperature and rate-of-rise
Response timeMore sensitive, react faster to firesMay react more quickly to rapid rise in temperature or when a certain temperature is reached
Best applicationIn homes; bedrooms, living room, hallways, basement, and officesGarage, workshops, factories, areas with high level of dust or steam

What are the Technologies Used in Each of Them?

Ionization and photoelectric are the two commonly used technologies in a smoke detector. Ionization smoke alarms are better at detecting fast-flaming fires. There are two tiny metal plates called electrodes that are connected to a battery which is called a circuit. They also contain a small amount of radioactive material, Americium-241, between two electrically charged plates, which creates a flow of electricity by ionizing the air. When smoke enters, it disrupts this ion flow, reducing the electrical current and triggering the alarm. Despite being radioactive, it is safe as it is sealed within the detector, emits low-energy alpha radiation and cannot penetrate the casing. 

HOW IONIZATION SMOKE DETECTOR WORKS

ionization-smoke-detectors-1024x576.jpg.webp__PID:9a6a433a-7d00-4c50-8225-3555d4464f49

Image source: roombanker.com

Photoelectric smoke alarms are best at detecting fires that smolder for a long time. These alarms shine a light into a sensing chamber at an angle away from the sensor. When smoke enters, it reflects the light onto the sensor, setting off the alarm. Smoke detectors typically react more quickly than heat detectors, and smoke detectors are ideal to place in homes due to their faster response.

HOW PHOTOELECTRIC SMOKE DETECTOR WORKS

photoelectric-smoke-alarms_large.webp__PID:22f46d1f-81e3-4515-bb57-2b38c8a786e2

Image source: nfpa.org

ComparisonIonization Smoke DetectorPhotoelectric Smoke Detector
Best applicationsBedrooms, living rooms, study areas, hallwaysBasement, bedrooms, living rooms, near kitchen areas
Response timeVery quick to detect small particles of fast-burning firesQuick to detect large particles from slow-smoldering fire

Heat detectors often use bimetallic strips and thermistors as key components to sense temperature changes. There are two common types of heat detector, fixed temperature and rate-of-rise. Fixed temperature heat detectors activate when their sensing element reaches a predetermined temperature, triggering an alarm. Some heat detector models use bimetallic strips, which consist of two metal layers that expand at different rates when exposed to heat, while others use thermistors, temperature-sensitive resistors that change resistance based on heat levels. In bimetallic strip-based heat detectors, once the temperature reaches a specific threshold, the strips bend due to the different expansion rates of the metals, completing an electrical circuit and triggering a fire alarm.

HOW FIXED TEMPERATURE HEAT DETECTOR WORKS

Spot-Type-Fixed-Temperature-Heat-Detector-Principle.webp__PID:484292ad-b93b-474b-8f26-fe53e9351edd

Image source: instrumentationtools.com

Rate-of-rise heat detectors activate when the temperature rises quickly within a short period, rather than reaching a fixed threshold. Thermistors can be used in both types of heat detector. Thermistor are temperature-sensitive resistors that act as sensors. Their electrical resistance changes predictably with temperature. When a rapid temperature change occurs, the detector’s electronic system processes the resistance shift, triggering the alarm.

OVERVIEW OF THERMISTOR HEAT DETECTOR 

3-s2.0-B978012800939000005X-f05-07-9780128009390.jpg__PID:d15efb07-3e86-4d94-9a68-7e860e62f546

Image source: sciencedirect.com

Some rate-of-rise heat detectors use thermistors, some rely on a differential pressure switch with an air chamber and diaphragm mechanism. They are sensitive to temperature changes that detect sudden, even small temperature changes and signals an alert. As the air in the sealed chamber expands from rising heat, it triggers the alarm by closing the electrical contact.

HOW DIFFERENTIAL PRESSURE RATE-OF-RISE HEAT DETECTOR WORKS

Rate-of-Rise-Heat-Detectors-Principle.webp__PID:a882e9b9-6ea5-42af-b5ae-d0e9ea42764f

Image source: instrumentationtools.com

ComparisonFixed Temperature Heat DetectorRate-of-Rise Heat Detector
Best applicationsBoiler rooms, garages, kitchens, storage areas, manufacturing plantsIndustrial facilities, chemical storage areas, restaurants, hotels, cafeterias, commercial buildings
Response timeWill trigger when preset temperature is exceededDetects rapid rise in temperature of an area

Where to Install Them

Smoke detectors should be strategically placed in bedrooms, living rooms, and hallways, basically areas where smoke is not typically present under normal conditions. Smoke detectors should also be placed away from vents, air conditioners, or fans, as airflow from these sources can disperse smoke particles, delaying detection or triggering false alarms. In contrast, heat detectors are best suited for locations prone to smoke, such as kitchens, where conventional smoke detectors might trigger false alarms. Additionally, heat detectors are ideal for environments containing highly flammable materials, chemicals, or excessive dust. Both types of detectors are mounted on the ceiling for optimal detection and responsiveness.

Key Takeaways and Important Highlights

The advanced technologies embedded in both heat and smoke detectors help ensure the safety of occupants in homes and buildings by providing early warnings in the event of a fire. Today, dual-sensor smoke detectors are available for increased accuracy in detecting both fast-flaming and slow-smoldering fires. These detectors combine ionization technology with photoelectric technology.

Similarly, dual-sensor heat detectors can detect slow-building and fast-spreading fires, reducing false alarms and ensuring prompt fire detection. Some heat detectors utilize thermistors, temperature-sensitive resistors that change resistance in response to heat, allowing precise temperature monitoring. Others use bimetallic strips, consisting of two metal layers that expand at different rates, where they bend when exposed to high temperatures, triggering an alarm.

Wired vs Wireless

Wireless detectors provide key advantages over traditional wired models, including simpler installation and the ability to connect multiple alarms for full-home protection. However, selecting the right wireless smoke detector requires careful consideration of factors such as battery life, sensor type, range, and compliance with safety standards to ensure optimal fire detection.

install.png__PID:f6875171-0ead-4f3a-8b73-3848cee1f6d9

Equipped with split-sectrum sensor and can connect up to 24 devices, our FF Smoke Detector PLUS can detect both slow-smoldering and fast-flaming fires for comprehensive fire protection

FF Smoke Detector PLUS

Get the FF Smoke Detector PLUS here

Here’s a short and clear wrap-up just for you!

  • Smoke detectors react faster and are typically more sensitive compared to heat detectors.
  • Types of smoke detectors: ionization, which detects fast-flaming fires and photoelectric, which detects slow-smoldering fires.
  • Types of heat detectors: fixed temperature, which triggers an alarm on a preset temperature and rate-of-rise, which triggers an alarm when temperature rapidly increases.
  • Dual sensor smoke detectors combine ionization and photoelectric technology for higher accuracy in detecting fires. 
  • Smoke detectors should be installed on every floor and in every room of a house, including the basement. Meanwhile, heat detectors are best placed in areas prone to dust and steam.

Sources

“Heat Detector - an Overview | ScienceDirect Topics.” Www.sciencedirect.com, www.sciencedirect.com/topics/engineering/heat-detector.

National Fire Protection Association. “Ionization vs Photoelectric.” Nfpa.org, 2023, www.nfpa.org/education-and-research/home-fire-safety/smoke-alarms/ionization-vs-photoelectric.

“Rate of Rise Thermal Detectors Working Principle | Instrumentation Tools.” Inst Tools, 5 Feb. 2019, instrumentationtools.com/rate-of-rise-thermal-detectors-working-principle/.

BACK TO TOP